On this special Columbus Day episode of the podcast, historian and author Craig Shirley joins the show to unpack the origins, significance, and modern controversy surrounding the holiday. Together, they trace the history of Columbus Day from its federal recognition in 1892 to its deep cultural importance within the Italian-American community — highlighting milestones such as Justice Antonin Scalia’s historic rise to the Supreme Court.

The conversation also explores how Columbus Day has become a political flashpoint in recent years, reflecting broader cultural divides over history and heritage. Shirley and Head turn their attention to the Trump era, examining how his presidency reshaped American patriotism, revived traditional values, and may have set the stage for a long-term political realignment toward Republican leadership.

Finally, Shirley offers a preview of his upcoming book, “Upheaval”, which delves into the profound cultural and political shifts sparked by the 2024 Trump campaign.